Knowing Our Place
Knowing Our Place is a series of reflections by Arthur Mullen, exploring the layered history of New Haven, through architecture, adaptive reuse, civic memory, and the meaning embedded in physical places. Moving through forgotten buildings, public spaces, landscapes, and historical moments, the series uses the story of one city to ask larger questions about identity, democracy, community, and what it means to belong somewhere. Through history, preservation, and observation, we examine how the places we inherit continue shaping the people we become.
Knowing Our Place
Mayor Roger Sherman and the Deal that Made High Street
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In 1784, New Haven faced severe congestion near Chapel Street, with tangled property lines hindering expansion. Mayor Roger Sherman, national statesman and expert surveyor, helped resolve this by orchestrating a land swap among himself, his brother-in-law James Prescott, and neighbor Mary Lucas.
Instead of cash, Sherman traded his Chapel Street frontage for Lucas’s land behind Prescott, while Lucas and Prescott exchanged parcels to create contiguous lots on either side of a new street. This pragmatic, neighborly negotiation, requiring sacrifices from Sherman and fellow civic leader James Hillhouse, meant no financial compensation was needed, as all parties agreed the land exchange settled any damages.
The making of High Street exemplifies how early American cities balanced rigid plans with evolving needs, blending property, family ties, and civic duty. Sherman’s precise, collaborative approach ensured city growth was achieved through compromise and mutual benefit, reflecting the hands-on, self-governing spirit that shaped both New Haven and the nation.
Source: https://rogershermanhouse.com/2019/06/11/roger-sherman-swapped-land-with-a-neighbor/